Even though critics think it’s really bad, this movie just reached the top of the Netflix charts – Kino News

Yes, critics and audiences often disagree. It happens time and time again that a film previously panned by the trade press turns out to be a smash hit – on the other hand, critics’ favorites regularly end up at the box office because there are hardly any viewers to unravel. a ticket.

This phenomenon can also be observed using signs. On Netflix, Ulknudel Adam Sandler comedies have been known to do well in terms of viewing numbers, while the films sometimes receive subpar ratings in reviews. Now with “Old fathersAnother title has risen to number one on the streaming giant, where the difference is noticeable in the ratings.

‘Old Dads’ tops Netflix charts

In “Old Dads”, three friends and late fathers Jack Kelly (Bill Burr), Connor Brody (Bobby Cannavale) and Mike Richards (Bokeem Woodbine) decide to sell their company to some young businessmen. But they quickly realize that they are no longer up to date. When it comes to upbringing, ethics and working conditions, they are constantly poor. Are their ideas outdated or has society gone mad?

“Old Dads” was written by stand-up legend Bill Burr, who also directed the film and can be seen as the lead actor in front of the camera. Since its release on October 20, 2023, the comedy has received a total of 13.3 million views, which equates to a viewing time of 23 million hours. What’s even more interesting than Netflix’s sheer numbers, and what’s really piqued audiences’ interest, are the various ratings for the film.

On the American review collection site Rotten tomatoes “The Old Fathers” was not well received by the trade press. Only 23 percent of reviews (out of a total of 35 reviews) were positive about the film. But the picture is different from the audience side: the film is fully celebrated here and achieves an 88 percent rating. And the audience reviews also speak for themselves:

Bill Burr doesn’t care about political correctness

In particular, the cultural clash between Generation X and Millennials seems to have been well received. User writes: “A really good movie. Bill Burr gets to the heart of the cultural conflict between Generation X and Millennials. It has also been positively confirmed that Bill Burr seems to care about so-called political correctness: “I liked it and found it funny and entertaining. It reminds me of films I enjoyed before the era of political correctness. […]”

At least for now, there are no signs that the large number of positive reviews is what is called “positive review bombing,” where a small group of users attempts to boost a film’s score with exaggerated positive reviews. The film seems to have created some tension in the audience – Bill Burr is also a very popular comedian, especially in America.

However, it’s worth noting that the reviews on Rotten Tomatoes reflect a slightly skewed rating picture, as they only measure whether someone generally rates a film as positive or negative. The film is quickly rated as “very nice” and therefore positive, but on detailed review, you soon realize the many weaknesses and the picture is not good at all.

On other sites, where the public can give a more precise rating and then calculate an average value, a different picture emerges: “Old Dads” has an average score of 6.3 out of a possible 10 on IMDb with nearly 10,000 votes. Although this rating is still higher than critics’ opinion (the average rating here is 4.3), it clearly shows that most people may have briefly enjoyed a strong film rather than celebrating it as a big discovery.

The next few days will show if the movie can stay in the top 10 on Netflix’s charts in the long run and perhaps even get even better next week. There certainly seems to be an interest in the Old Fathers…

If you want to get an idea of ​​the film for yourself, you can watch the trailer here to get the mood: